Academic vocabulary
Unfortunately, both your textbooks
and you seem to be rather too much in love with the verb “to state” as being the
best means of referring to a comment or passage by another writer. But we have
plenty of more incisive alternatives. When a writer presents an argument, and
you reference it, you might say that the author (whom I here designate
as male):
Accepts
---- Here
you may be in disagreement with the writer, and about to make a point that
challenges his belief, or you are observing that the author is agreeing to some fact with which he is not entirely happy, but knows he cannot change.
Advances the idea that ---- The writer has proposed something; put an idea
on the table.
Advocates
---- The
writer, like a lawyer or campaigner, favors a particular approach.
Affirms
---- The
implication is you share the belief.
Alleges
---- Use
if you are very doubtful or skeptical of his claims.
Allows
---- Here
the writer is conceding a point, admitting an exception, permitting something
that may run counter to his argument.
Announces
---- The
writer has made a statement that is in some way introductory to a point – just
as one might announce an event before it takes place.
Argues
---- The writer has
constructed a thesis, made a point, presented a reasoned argument and is trying
to persuade us.
Asserts
---- The
writer states his position forcefully – your use of this word implies a certain
distancing of your own view from his.
Attests (to the view that, to the truth of the
fact) ---- The writer is speaking from personal
experience, and is somehow a witness to the point he is making.
Avows
---- Use
if the writer said whatever he said in a rather solemn spirit of conviction and
belief.
Claims
---- The
writer is saying this, but, as with allege (q.v.), you are standing back
and not necessarily accepting his view.
Concedes
---- Like allows (q.v.),
but with an even stronger sense that a contradiction has been detected and
acknowledged.
Confirms
---- You
are putting yourself on the same side as the writer and suggesting that what he
says was essentially a restatement of something that is already true.
Contends
---- Fancy and
more forceful word for argues (q.v.), with a hint of a continuing debate in
which one position is contrasted with another.
Conveys the idea, message, notion that... ---- Best used if the writer has succeeded in
presenting an idea through descriptive or allusive language.
Declares ---- Use if he is making a statement with
“political” or rhetorical intent.
Demonstrates
---- Like shows (q.v.),
but the notion that something has been scientifically or logically proved is even
stronger.
Divulges/reveals ---- Use when what the writer has said is news to
you, or, at any rate, is intended by the writer to represent a discovery for
whoever is reading.
Endorses the view/idea that ---- The writer is willing to sign off on or back an idea (which you
are now about to state).
Explains
---- Simple
enough; best to restrict your use of it to when you are essentially in
agreement with his point.
Highlights
---- A stronger
version of points out (q.v.): the writer takes one element of his argument
and gives it precedence.
Indicates
---- Interesting
word: can mean either to point out (q.v.), in which case the writer may have
an instance or example in mind and has put his finger on it; or to suggest (q.v.), in
which case the writer is indirectly alluding to or pointing a finger in the
general direction of a concept.
Insists
---- He
is reiterating a point already made, or is sticking to a position already
implicitly or explicitly articulated.
Maintains
---- Like argues (q.v.),but
with the implication that this is a belief personally held by the writer,to
which he is more attached than if he were merely arguing it.
Mentions
---- Use
this when you isolate one point or example from several that the writer has
provided.
Notes
---- Not
as neutral as it sounds. If you say a writer notes something, then you and
he are accepting that that which was noted is true and merely needed pointing
out.
Points out
---- Like notes (q.v.), in
that you and he both accept the fact at face-value. It also conveys the idea of
selecting one element as being of particular importance.
Proclaims
---- A strong
word, to be used sparingly. It refers to a public announcement of a belief.A
Republic is proclaimed, as is the Second Coming of Christ.
Professes
---- The
only thing you really profess is a belief ---- not an idea.
Promulgates an idea, theory ---- The writer is setting out some sort of belief
and hoping that it will be widely taken up.
Proposes
---- Like advances (q.v.),except
the writer has given a more definitive or formal structure to the idea being put
forward.
Propounds
---- Like promulgate (q.v.),except
the writer is perhaps less anxious for the idea to be taken up as a popular
cause.
Puts forward the idea that ---- Like advance and propose (q.v.).
Recites (the reasons, causes, facts, arguments) ---- Hard to use correctly – usually this will
refer to a list, whether explicitly or implicitly referred to Often one recites words or beliefs learned by heart, and the verb carries the idea of something a little dull or self-evident that is being repeated.
.
Reports
---- Limit
this to where the writer is“bringing back”information from somewhere, like a
journalist on the front line, or a financial analyst who has examined the books
and is now presenting his findings.
Reveals
---- Only
use this if there is some sort of ta-da! unveiling of a point in what the
writer has said.
Says
---- A pretty
neutral word, nothing at all wrong with it, and usually to be preferred to states.
Sets forth the notion, idea, arguments ---- Arranges the arguments in an orderly manner,
much as a stall-owner might set out his wares for display.
Shows
---- The
statement is backed by some sort of evidence or proof of its veracity.
Stresses
---- Please
use this only to isolate one aspect of what the writer has said.
Suggests
---- Either (i) the author was tentative in saying it, or, (ii) you are drawing a conclusion that the
author may not have explicitly stated. If used with should (iii) it is often used to indicate that the writer has offered advice - The author suggests that sugar should be treated as if it were a toxic drug.
Underlines/underscores ---- Like stresses (q.v.). Italian students,
please do not use this as if it were synonymous with “says” or “states”.
Voices the idea that ---- The writer is acting as spokesman for a pre-existing idea held by others. Similar to advocates.
Please be aware that the verbs below cannot
stand on their own before a noun clause; they require a direct or oblique
object.
Inform – The essay informs us about
how the cargo cult culture of the Easter Islands developed....
Tell – By showing how a young man can
be corrupted by influence writer tells us that societal
norms...
Apprise – In his examination of the
individual, Larry Siedentop apprises us of several interesting facts
about early Christianity...
Advise – This is often
used without an object, but it is better with one. He advises people to
avoid... NOT He advises to avoid....
No comments:
Post a Comment